September 14, 2026 · Equipment Capital Index
Equipment Loan vs. Equipment Lease: How to Choose, With Worked Numbers
Ask five equipment dealers whether you should lease or borrow and you will get five confident answers, most of them shaped by whichever product that dealer’s finance partner happens to sell. The honest answer is that the two structures solve different problems, and the right pick depends on what you want to own at the end, what you can deduct along the way, and how much cash you want to keep in the business today.
This guide walks through the three structures you will actually be offered, runs the same $120,000 machine through each one, and explains where the real differences hide. The payment figures below use an illustrative 8.25% APR, the same sample rate our own machine pages show, and are meant to demonstrate the mechanics. They are not a quote.
The three structures, in plain terms
An equipment loan is the simplest. A lender advances money, you buy the machine in your own name, and you repay principal plus interest over a fixed term. The lender takes a security interest in the equipment (usually by filing a UCC-1 financing statement) until the loan is paid off. From day one you own the asset, you carry it on your balance sheet, and you claim the depreciation.
A $1 buyout lease (sometimes called a capital lease or finance lease) is a loan wearing a lease’s clothing. Payments are structured to fully repay the equipment’s cost, and at the end you buy it for a nominal amount, often one dollar. Because ownership is effectively a foregone conclusion, the IRS generally treats a $1 buyout lease as a conditional sale, which means you are treated as the owner for tax purposes and can generally take depreciation or a Section 179 deduction, just as you would with a loan. If you want the full picture on those deductions, our post on Section 179 and bonus depreciation in 2026 covers what changed.
A fair market value (FMV) lease, also called an operating lease or true lease, is a genuine rental. The payments cover only part of the machine’s cost, because the lessor expects to own a valuable asset at the end. At the end of the term you typically choose between returning the equipment, renewing the lease, or buying it at its then-current fair market value. The lessor claims the depreciation; you generally deduct the lease payments as an operating expense.
One machine, three structures
Take a $120,000 wheel loader with a five-year (60-month) term at an illustrative 8.25%.
| Loan, 20% down | $1 buyout lease, no down | FMV lease, 30% residual | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash at signing | $24,000 down | $0 (plus fees) | $0 (plus fees) |
| Amount financed | $96,000 | $120,000 | $120,000 less residual |
| Monthly payment | about $1,958 | about $2,448 | about $1,961 |
| Total of payments | about $117,500 | about $146,900 | about $117,600 |
| Total cash out, including down payment | about $141,500 | about $146,900 | about $117,600, plus any buyout |
| What you own at the end | The machine | The machine | Nothing, unless you buy it |
Look at the first and third columns. The loan and the FMV lease land within a few dollars of each other each month, but they get there differently. The loan asks for $24,000 up front and leaves you owning a machine. The lease asks for nothing up front and leaves you with a decision: the lessor assumed the machine would be worth around $36,000 (30% of $120,000) at month 60. If it is worth more, a buyout at FMV costs you more than you expected; if it is worth less, you can simply hand it back and the lessor absorbs the shortfall.
The $1 buyout column is the one people misread. Its payment is higher because you are financing 100% of the price and paying it all off. It is not a worse deal than the loan; it is the same deal with no down payment, which is worth something in a year when cash is tight.
Where the real differences hide
Residual risk. In an FMV lease the lessor takes the risk that the machine is worth less than projected. In a loan or $1 buyout, you do. For equipment that holds its value well, such as many categories of heavy construction machinery, that risk is modest. For equipment with fast technology cycles or heavy wear, it is real, and it is the strongest argument for an FMV structure.
Usage limits. FMV leases frequently carry hour or mileage caps and return-condition clauses. Exceed the allowed hours on an excavator and you may owe overage charges at return. If your business runs a machine hard, read this section of the contract before you read the rate.
Customization and attachments. If you will modify a machine in ways that do not come off cleanly (a custom body, permanent attachments), a lease return becomes complicated. Ownership structures avoid the argument.
Flexibility at the end. A loan ends the day you make the last payment. A true lease ends with a choice, which is valuable if you routinely refresh equipment every few years and dislike remarketing used machines yourself.
Balance sheet treatment. Under the accounting standard ASC 842, most leases longer than twelve months now appear on a lessee’s balance sheet as a right-of-use asset and a lease liability, so the old advantage of “off balance sheet” operating leases has largely disappeared for companies following GAAP. If a bank or surety reads your financial statements, assume both structures show up as obligations.
The tax angle, honestly
The tax comparison is where generalities fail, so treat this section as a map of questions to ask your CPA rather than a conclusion.
With a loan or $1 buyout, your first-year deduction can be large. For equipment placed in service after January 19, 2025, 100% bonus depreciation applies, and Section 179 offers a deduction up to a statutory cap for qualifying purchases. A business with a strong year can use that to meaningfully reduce taxable income. With an FMV lease, you deduct payments as they are made, which spreads the benefit evenly across the term.
Neither is automatically better. A growing business with a high-profit year ahead may prefer the front-loaded deduction. A business that expects lower profits next year may prefer smoother deductions. The situation that changes the analysis most is the one where your taxable income is low: Section 179 cannot exceed your business’s net income, so a deduction you cannot use is worth less than it looks.
A decision framework
Lean toward a loan or $1 buyout when you plan to keep the machine for most of its useful life, you want to claim depreciation, and the equipment is something you would not casually replace in three to five years. Most owner-operators and contractors fall here.
Lean toward an FMV lease when technology or condition changes quickly, when you value lower payments over ownership, when you can reliably stay inside hour limits, or when your lender or accountant prefers the expense treatment.
Lean toward a short-term rental instead of either when your annual utilization is low enough that paying for a full-time machine is hard to justify. Our post on renting versus buying heavy equipment shows how to find that break-even.
Questions to ask before you sign
- What is the purchase option at the end, stated as a number or a formula, not a promise?
- Are there hour, mileage, or condition limits, and what do overages cost?
- Is there a prepayment penalty or early termination fee, and how is it calculated?
- Which fees are rolled into the financed amount? Documentation and origination fees change the true cost, as we explain in our guide to the real cost of equipment financing.
- Does the lender require a personal guarantee, and does it survive after the equipment is sold?
- Who carries insurance, and what happens if the machine is stolen or totaled?
The bottom line
A loan and an FMV lease can have nearly identical payments, which is exactly why comparing them on payment alone misleads. Compare them on what you hold at the end, what risk you carry in between, and what the tax treatment does to your actual cash. When those three line up with your plans for the machine, the choice is usually obvious. When they do not, the structure is probably being chosen for the lender’s convenience rather than yours.
You can see how monthly payments change across equipment categories on our Rate Index, and every machine page shows the amortization assumptions behind its figures. For the exact math, see our methodology. This article is general information, not tax, legal, or financing advice. Confirm structure-specific details with your lender and a qualified CPA before you commit.
See real financing estimates for heavy construction .